right now, never heard him. >> yeah. uncovered this case for about seven years now, and i also have never heard of this young man gary pharaoh. he is on the stand. he clearly, according to his testimony, he has a banking relationship with michael cohen, he was assigned to cohen's account because quote, cohen was known to be challenging mr. fair. apparently it was good with difficult clients but he insisted cohen is not difficult, but we haven't gotten to really why he is on the stand. we don't know if this is gonna be about payments to stormy daniels or cohen's home equity line. it's unclear, but stay tuned because we continue to get these lives updates from inside the court bit of a mystery late on a friday afternoon, paula reid. thank you so much i've or sanchez in new york and i'm wolf blitzer here in washington. much more of our specialty what coverage of the trial is coming up and i'll be back in two hours in the situation room 6:00 p.m. eastern. but the lead with jake tapper starts right now cnn's

breaking news welcome to the lead on jake tapper, right now, right this minute. i knew witness in donald trump's hush money cover up trial. the prosecution just called it's third witness. his name is gary pharaoh. gary pharaoh is a banker who worked with michael cohen at the time that the payments were made to former playboy model, karen mcdougal and porn actress and director stormy daniels, both of whom alleged romantic entanglements of sorts with mr. donald trump. this comes after rona graph was called as the second witness in the trial. rona graph, she's on the screen right there. she's a longtime trump assistance. she worked for trump since he hired her in 1987 after she cold calls to trump organization were on a graph, testified i'd two contacts you maintained at the trump

organization were for karen mcdougal & stormy daniels run a graph was on the stand for less than half an hour earlier today, trump's attorneys cross-examined david pecker, the former tabloid magnate and longtime friend of donald trump. let's dive into all of this with my panel. so jamie put rona graph into context for us a lot of people who know trump world were excited about this testimony. she was a vice president for the firm. she was a very important player in his world she testified today very testified very briefly. >> right. so loyal trustee, gatekeeper for those of us going back, who wanted to interview donald trump. that's who you call she was she knew everything was going on back when he was like a real estate tycoon and that's it back in the ice age. that was hey, you know, you want but she also her

her desk was right outside his office. she was within earshot and she she is the inner circle of the inner circle. she placed the calls. she made the schedules, she knew is traveling arrangements. politico had a headline on a profile of her and it was neat to reach trump call rona. so she knew everything that was going on into someone who was brought in to worked for norma, actually, his other negative assistant who trump has this saying with his executive assistant, his dad was the same way and they're deeply attached and someone who really knows everything does everything for him rona was that person. and even when he went into the white house, jake, she was someone who still had that direct line. his old context would still reach out to rona to get her to get a message to him. she even trained the former white the white house let's employee who went on to sit outside the oval office and then occupied that role. madeline western out and

obviously, she was only on the stand briefly, but she was there to get some records into the record and basically to say stormy daniels was seen outside of trump's office on the 26th floor of trump tower, and that karen mcdougal and stormy daniels is contact numbers were in his contacts. >> interesting. so let's talk talk about the guy on the witness stand right now. his name is gary pharaoh he's a former senior managing director at first republic bank. he was just asked about the issue of what does kyc stand for? he says it means know your customer, be sure they are who they say they are. an emails right now being shown to the jury what is the significance of gary pharaoh? why is he testifying? >> i mean, obviously it's still underway, but appears he's essentially cohen's banker. if i sort of understand what so what would that mean that he's going to testify as to the payments? the payments the shell company, the mechanics of the payments, right? obviously, we've all been focused on largely are many of us have been focused it's done sort of the more salacious elements of this upper arm or interesting, they are more interesting, but

the crime actually has to do with all of this somewhat banal record keeping stuff so this is a case where i think we're going to actually see quite a few somewhat dull witnesses producing things like documents, ledgers invoices, things like that, just have to come i'm into evidence to complete this case, which is which is not meant as a bust on gary pharaoh. he might be a very fascinating di, but it's testimony itself is just about record keeping. >> an interesting name again to carry, fair. i got the greatest names of witnesses, pharaoh packer graph. >> anyway i'm walking away from yes but one thing to just point out, there's a couple of tactics at play here. one is if you're a prosecutor, i used to do some multi-week cases where you'd have good witnesses and bad witnesses mixed in. you liked the idea of leaving them with something solid, unchallenged, good at the end of the week. so it may be that these are basically glorified records, custodian so basically introducing some paperwork for the jury to look at at for 30

before they go home and go oh, there were checks. or there were meetings where there were contexts. it's also smart for the defense at this point to keep it dull, to basically not spend any time cross-examining people where you have no real reason to gain anything because they're not establishing criminal nauta or they're not establishing controversial points. so let them go continue to focus on cohen and wait for that moment well, let me just say so. the email that was just shown that now they're discussing it's from gary pharaohs assistant and him that michael cohen, his clients at the time called on october 11, when 2016? >> yeah. i'm sure we'll find out why that matters i'm sure there are no cameras in the courtrooms. >> no, no, i can do interesting, but i just want to like yes, their records, folks, but i don't think we should lose sight of the significance of what graph actually put in to evidence will come back to graph in a second. but gary fair received another female two days later. please return michael cohen's call when you are available today regarding

an important matters. >> this is why this matters is because he is trying to arrange the payment to stormy daniels, which is what all of this is about. michael cohen. from michael cohen, maybe it's not as salacious, but this is actually what the trial and the crime itself. >> it is michael cohen was contacting this bank because he they'd been having this discussion about ami and david pecker is the firewood owned the national enquirer? >> yes. they've been having the discussion on them making the payment to stormy daniels and essentially david pecker or didn't want anything to do it. he did not want to be in cahoots with a porn star making this payment to her. and it came to this point where michael cohen was trying to reach trump. he was under pressure to do this and finally said, i'm just going to do it myself and drew down a home equity line that's why this exchange happening right now pharaoh received another email two days later, please return michael cohen's call when you are available today regarding an important merit, a matter pharaoh calls cohen who told him he wanted to open a new llc account. >> cohen said the account was for capital real estate. pharaoh says, let me bring in

some other attorneys we have with us today to discuss criminal defense attorney bill brennan, trial attorney misty marris, and manhattan criminal defense attorney stacey schneider. stacey was also a former contestant on the apprentice and knows the judge, as well as a district attorney, alvin bragg, as well as mr. trump. obviously, from her time on the apprentice. let's start with you. bill brennan because right now this testimony from gary pharaoh who worked for michael cohen is looks like it's leading up towards evidence of this llc corporation, which some might call a shell corporation to hide the payment that he made to stormy daniels on trump's behest that is the allegation anyway, mr. brennan hello, jake and i agree with the former prosecutors said, you know, you may want to end the week on especially i think they're not in session monday, if i'm correct about that, that's right. >> three-day weekend. and on innocuous testimony, especially following up the 34 year-old

had a 34 year employee. the administrative assistants, who apparently spoken glowing terms of the defendant, said he was respectful, he was wonderful to work for. i don't think you want the jury, if you're the prosecutor von prosecuting his case? left with that the mall over for three days, plus you need this type of kind of boilerplate innocuous testimony to corroborate the later allegations of cohen and the paper will go in, so it's not going to always be as salacious is pecker was and you have to fill in with these fill in the blanks witnesses stacy, tell us about rona graph. >> do you know her at all? have you encountered her at all? >> what is your experience with her? >> she obviously it was trump's longtime assistant who testified for about half an hour earlier today yes. >> rona is the loveliest woman on the planet. when i was on the show. if the we wanted to

stay in touch with donald trump after the show, the person we were told to contact is rona she was indeed his gatekeeper she had an amazing relationship with donald trump. i always wondered how she worked for such a difficult boss. she was always pleasant and i think this was very helpful after david pecker's testimony, which was really damaging for donald trump about all this alleged nefarious conduct to have somebody soften him, like rona hu still whose cared about him. all these years. i understood i wasn't in the courtroom, but after she got up and left to leave the testimony, i think donald trump stood up and touched her hand, and that's a big difference from what his behavior during jury selection when the jurors were entering the room, he didn't even stand up for them, but he stood up for rona today. >> so mr. do you marris, let me tell you some of the stuff going on in the courtroom right now. in an october 13, 2016

email. and again, the significance of october 2016, a right before the presidential election. b, this is during the hotbed of activity about making sure that stormy daniels story or allegation does not get out there october 13th email michael cohen need out open for michael cohen. this is from gary pharaoh, need account open from michael cohen. immediately he wants no address on the checks. he also notes that an llc not having an address is not unusual. pharaoh says that cohen call to set up an count for resolution consultants llc i loved the fact that in any anytime there's any story about allegations of misdeeds, the llc always has the most boring, innocuous name and that's one for the history books resolution consultants, llc. i'm all are already falling asleep, but i've been obviously it was anything but boring. what was going on misty, right. certainly seeking a resolution. right. so

there's a couple of really important points here. number one, jake, you nailed it. the timing. remember this is all part of the prosecution's narrative that this is right around the time the access hollywood tape has become public, trump team is in panic mode to get rid of his stormy daniels story. so that's all going to speak to some of the elements that tie this payment directly to the election. now the other pieces, every single document and communication & transaction relating to this payment is obviously a key and critical part of the case. and to have these shell companies, this is all speaking to that idea of a conspiracy trying to mask these payments as something that they're not. and remember, that is a fundamental part of the prosecution's case as far as this all being unlawful conduct because the payments themselves aren't unlawful. it's that were they properly reported? are they related to the campaign where they related to the election? so all of this testimony, while foundational authenticating

documents, really, really important to the merits of the prosecution's case. >> let me call on my favorite my fellow rather philadelphian, mr. brennan and permit me a moment of geographical snobbery because delaware is being raised, the jury is seeing pages of documents that show resolution consultants, llc was created by michael cohen, has a delaware entity we'd like to make fine of new jersey in philadelphia& bill, maybe you can explain why delaware is always where the shady corporations are headquartered i can jake because delaware many years ago crafted laws of incorporation. >> we're very favorable for those who wish to incorporate. so that's why we see, i think per capita, it's the out of the 50 states. it's the number one but i'd just like to respond to a couple of the comments that i heard. it's probably just the dna that i have being a defense lawyer you have to remember that the defense here

is likely to be and i think we've seen a preview. is that payments if they were made and if they were made to these individuals, ms clifford and ms mcdougal, they were paid to avoid a very embarrassing and shameful scenario that the defendant will encounter with his wife and family and that that sells to people and i think that when you look at i wasn't in court today. i just know what i've read and what i've heard from you guys, but when you think about this prosecution, they have to get it to the other crime to make the felony stick, they have to show that if these things were done, they weren't to avoid personal problems. we were to affect either campaign finance laws or the election. and i thought i read or heard that mr. pecker stumbled into some type of meeting in the white house. were director comey and secretary pompeii or were there and the prosecution seems to be saying, well, you're in the

meeting with two big officials. i mean, that doesn't make him a coconspirator that makes some forrest gump i mean, the guy stumbling around and walks into a meeting that's proof of nothing. so i don't know that pecker's testimony was that damaging so far, i suspect they'll fill in the gaps or attempt to fill them in with cohen. and i suspect that we'll see a much more aggressive line of cross-examination with them so jurors are being shown emails right now between cohen and pharaoh setting up a bank account for resolution consultants, llc everyone stick with me. we're close to wrapping for the week in the manhattan hush money cover up for i'll keep it here as we watch prosecutors try to finish out as the court adjourns for the weekend, three-day weekend for the jury. we're back in a moment the white house correspondents dinner live tomorrow at seven eastern on cnn today. america's beverage companies are models might still look the same, but they can be remade in a whole new way thanks to you.

>> we're getting bottles back and we've developed a way to make new ones from 100% recycled plastic new bottles made using no new plastic, you'll be seeing more of these bottles in more places. >> and when we get more of them back we can use less new plastic bottles are made to be remade hi it's christina again. >> i'm here to tell you about an all new special offer from my friends at jacuzzi bathroom model that you don't want to miss, you already know jacuzzi has been making water-filled great for more than 65 years. and now they're bringing you this special tv offer. were waving all installation costs and postponing all payments for up to one year to cruzy bathroom model has a design you love at a price you can afford and best of all, they can install it. and as little as one day with no stress at no are you ready to see your new shower here it is it's

fabulous. >> taking a shower had gone from being a joy to being a burden. i was afraid i would fall. i called and just one day i had a shower. i could feel safe in no matter your situation, jacuzzi bathroom model has a solution in for you from a safer, easy entry shower with features like grab bars and a seat to keep you feeling comfortable & independent at home to a stunning family bath or how about a luxurious upgrade with a timeless design that will look great for years to come. plus, they're built to last with a lifetime warranty from an iconic brand. you know, you can trust it was done in the same day we did not have to wait it's absolutely perfect that's exactly what i was dreaming of. >> if you haven't already experienced what jacuzzi bathroom model can do for you? you your family, and your home, don't wait any longer. now is the best time to call. it's never been easier. take advantage of this specialty. the offer today. call or go

online right now for a limited time offer, only weeks left to get waves installation and no interests and no payments for up to one year go-to jacuzzi bathroom model.com, or call 800 163978. that's 805, 163978 call now structured settlement had died no go it's your money use it when you need it now, adt professionally installed google nest products, you're all set are in the system. >> we should go with the most

trusted name and home security as the intelligence of google, you have a home with no worries brought to you by adt life is better with the credit god's on your side rewards, ones available you are now accessible to the many credit one bank get cashback rewards. >> lins, large, closed captioning brought to you by mesobook.com her firm. >> only represents mesothelioma victims and their families. if you or a loved one who has been diagnosed with mesothelioma call us now welcome back to cnn's coverage of the manhattan hush money cover up trial. we are still here in studio and the jury is still listening to testimony. cohen, according to the paperwork being presented to the jury about the llc the corporation being set up by michael collins when in order to make payments to stormy daniels allegedly at

donald trump's behalf, asked per the paperwork cohen described the entity. this is resolution. what's called resolution consulting, llc or something like that. yeah. you consultants llc describe the entities function to be management consultant included hr and marketing. >> cohen was the only authorized signatory for the account. now, you were saying that this may sound very boring and bookkeeper r3, but actually it's not, it's actually important. >> yeah, well, look, let's let's talk about why that prosecutors would be introducing all this. obviously, it tells part of the story, but part of what their need to prove is that there was some knowledge or awareness that there would be legal implications concerning the way that this payment was booked. one of the pieces of circumstantial evidence that you can produce as a prosecutor to help shore up testimony like this is evidenced that you are doing something very sneaky. you're concealing things like management consulting. there was no management consulting going on. right. >> so while he was being

consulted to manage stormy day correct? right. so all of this has an air of impropriety about it, right? it has an air of impropriety about it. and as you said, delaware, just joking i just want to go back to run a graph to short, i guess you said you liked him or whatever. but this is the gatekeeper who worked for donald trump from 1987 for decades. >> yeah. >> colin, by the way, checked know on the forum when asked if the entity was associated with political fundraising or political action? committee, unquote. is that significant yeah. i mean, it's a lie because it was associated with i'm going to definitely associated with political fundraising and some sort of pack. there was an ongoing campaign, whether i'm sure there's some loyalty way of trying to defend that language, but the jury's not going to see it that way. >> but make your point about graph. yeah, ronna graph so what does she put into evidence? you put an evidence that in the trump organization records ronna graphs, excuse me, stormy daniels contact information was in there. okay. >> the prosecutors are slowly trying to establish that this a fair actually happened with

stormy daniels, correct that whatever was the event, whatever isn't really in a fair yes. >> whatever the interaction the jury won't have to take stormy daniels word for it. right? because trump is tried to say, oh, she's alive, she's making it all up to sell books and money. but why would he have her contact info in her in his by the way, this account, pharaoh is the bank, did all of our work worked to establish cohen's account but quota deposit was never made in the accounts of the account, never went live. so it confirmed the account was not open. so why does that matter? so as this this is a debt account. it just looks like a lot of machinations that are designed to just conceal this from scrutiny okay. we know what michael cole was doing. he's actually said this publicly that he wanted to not only hide this from scrutiny, but also hide it from his wife. he later, from his own life or michael cohen's wife. so this was it wasn't just easy for michael cohen to go again, $130,000. he's talked about the immense pressure he was under and he only went to do it because essentially faced no other option to get this money.

right? it felt like they needed to pay stormy daniels and do so quickly because she had her attorney. but what they were dragging it out pass the election. and then once they hit the election, they'd never get the money because michael cohen didn't have millions of dollars in the bank. he just draw down a home equity loan omega. let me come back on one second. let me go out to paula reid it is outside the courthouse right now with all the latest paula yeah. >> jake, i was just thinking about the gag order and creative ways that trump has found a way around it because we do expect him to speak after court really, it possibly in a matter of minutes we always currently subject to an expanded gag order where he can't as miss defendants cannot attack witnesses, tac members of the jury. now it's been expanded to include prosecutors and family members of the judge. now, i'm also monitoring sidestream on talking to you. they're still talking about setting up that llc i agree with you, jake, not the most exciting thing we've seen throughout the trial. >> but trump has tried to find ways of working around this gag order because he according to prosecutors, just blatantly

violated it multiple times, particularly going after cohen is trying some work arounds like quoting other people, including a fox news host to raise questions about the jury. >> he's also come out. we've seen him a few times at the end of cte with a stack of articles and quoted attacks on people he's not supposed to directly attack. >> now what was clear from the hearing earlier this week on a gag order that that is probably going to be a violation. >> so something we saw this morning for the first time was him pointing to his allies on the hill, gop allies who are now making many these arguments for him. now, again, i'm looking down at the side stream. mr. pharaoh is it's just talking about the urgency that michael cohen had while he was setting up this llc. but it's gonna be really interesting to watch as trump comes out of court, if he continues this tactic because he cannot directly the attack people like for example, matthew colangelo, one of the prosecutors here, who formerly worked the biden justice department, it appears that now instead he's having folks on the hill do that, and then he and his allies will point to their reports, or their remarks. i'm also curious to

see prosecutors reaction to this. so that's definitely want him to watch for in a couple of minutes when trump addresses the press. >> okay. every time michael cohen spoke to me, he gave a sense of urgency and this was one of those times testimony from greg pharaoh, who was the banker for michael cohen, and we are hearing information about the accounts that michael cohen set up to allegedly pay stormy daniels allegedly at the behest of donald trump pharaoh confirms that the new llc that cohen wanted to open was essential consultants, llc as opposed to resolution consultants, ll see jim. >> well, i shouldn't end. and personal motivation only 11 see that would have been helpful. but look, i think there's a couple of things that are interesting here. if i'm the prosecution, i've got pharaoh on the stand. i'm going to do what i can to make him go to the buzzer today. do not leave time for cross-examination because if there is cross, they're going to leave this jury with a weekend. it'll be a friendly cross, frankly, it's not gonna be some big hostile perry mason moment. but you're gonna get him to concede cohen

being dishonest, cohen being in charge, cohen committing misdeeds. it's the first substantive moment of being able to say this guy cohen is the weasel at the heart of everything and if you leave the jury with that for three days, it's a great moment for the defense, so it'll be interesting to see if they start asking questions like, how do you like the weather in new york? just to give the 5:00. what's your take on this? >> i think that's a student inaccurate i will just say that the phrase that i was searching for a little bit earlier concerning all these machinations and the secrecy and the misrepresentations that reflects consciousness of wrongdoing but michael cohen knew what he was doing was wrong because you don't go through all of these efforts unless you're doing something wrong, you feel bad about. and i agree that the defense is going to be that this was all michael cohen's do can i say i see it completely differently than you do, which is that it's michael cohen out for his own good doing what he needs to do what i'm seeing these dates and that michael cohen is urgently trying to get in touch with this banker they are trying to paint a picture of michael cohen is stressed. michael cohen is under

pressure. he has someone who he has in mind as he is trying to open this count and desperately get money. they he doesn't really have access to and that we already know he's hiding from his wife at the time and concealing it. i think they're trying to paint a different picture that he is actually under pressure and he has stressed but there's no wrong because it's october to that hasn't 16 right before the elections. stormy story coming out. >> it's october 26 when he calls back. i mean, we are truly a week away from the election and they're saying they're basically trying to frame michael cohen is someone who is stressed. >> i'm not disagreeing with the image are trying to create. i'm saying yeah, how's that going to play out? do you think michael cohen is going to come off? often as poor overworked bob cratchit from the christmas carol with scrooge leaning on him or is he going to come off as a first-class perjure and liar and disbarred lawyer he is going to come across also as someone who used to be very loyal to donald trump. >> and did his bidding. and that's what this feels like. we're getting close closer and closer to the election resolution went to essential central consultants, llc. he's not setting this up because he

has a problem with stormy daniels. he said in this up because donald trump has a problem with stormy daniels and they don't want it to come out before the election. in the wake of access hollywood, right? >> donald trump is fighting for his political life after the access hollywood tape dropped a few weeks before, just to put everybody in the context of october 2016 along come stormy daniels, who is alleging she had a sexual encounter with donald trump. he does not want that information to be known by if voters in october 2016 with the election coming up, that's the story that prosecutors are presenting and michael cohen, according to the prosecution set up these accounts to pay stormy daniels to hide the payments. not only from johnny law, but from his wife, according to michael cohen, under business narrative for this second llc, that michael cohen was setting up this one essential consulting llc it

states, cohen was opening the account for a real estate consulting company to collect fees for consulting regarding real estate. the prosecutor mangold. she says she's at a natural stopping point for the day. it's for 20 7:00 p.m. they said four 30 would be the time that they would end for the weekend. judge merchan says, we will call it a week and as giving the jury instructions, this is exactly jim trusty, what you said, you would do if you were the prosecutor, establish some of these little facts, don't let the defense have a moment ago, adam. >> yeah. i mean, that's and look, there's nothing sinister about that. there's an element of theater to trial, and i think they're been in north carolina four 4.4 corner defense. right. it's not that before corner it's not four to 2.5 times that bad. but this is essential. my point is not that it's not important evidence. they're looking for stuff that's not controversial. they want, don't want to leave with their chin and have these moments of really getting sidetracked long before cohen gets on the stand if you're the defense, the fight is not whether or not there was a

relationship with stormy. it's not whether or not there was an nda. i mean, that's really not it ultimately what you're focusing on is cone and you're looking at the ledger and you're saying is the difference between a crime and a not crime that you didn't say four nda after legal services. that's a really thin divide between criminal and non-criminal. and that's that's where jury instructions are going to be huge way down the road, but that's also where closing arguments gonna go. >> donald trump in inside the courtroom, just hit his attorney, todd blanche on the arm and leaned over to tell him something. again, color that we're not seeing because there are no cameras in the courtroom in new york, which many people, many legal experts have disagreed with. we are also waiting for donald trump to come outside of the courtroom and speak to the cameras. you see the place there that he will deliver the message? >> yeah. i was just wanted to say that i think whether or not the relationship is stormy daniels occurred. i mean, we all take it for granted, but in a trial setting, act go is a material fact fact, because trump's position, including

either think the position is lawyer took an opening in the opening statement, is that this interaction didn't occur. well, they say it never happened, correct. >> and so every lie that the prosecution can establish that the defense has is putting forth as part of their defense helps them interesting.& but we know that there are pictures of donald trump with stormy daniels. he doesn't deny knowing her. right. and she says that she tried to get a job on celebrity apprentice. the issue is whether or not they had any sort of sexual interlude. so i'm not sure. >> and she's inconsistent on that too. they've got her on record saying it didn't happen because she signed that nda to be good been with judge merchan reminding jurors that the court is dark on monday and is going to return tuesday at 9:30 a.m. eastern. jurors are exiting the courtroom, which means that we expect the defendant himself will exit the courtroom as well. but what are they established so far factually? if anything, that establishes that stormy daniels and donald trump did have a sexual encounter? i don't think any

here as of as of now, nothing zero. there are a lot of people in donald trump's contexts. you're probably in his contacts that wrote i'm probably in them. i mean, there were a lot of people who are in the phone book. that said what's the motivation for paying her all of this money? one of the interesting things about david pecker is testimony about here comes the defendant himself watching, walking up to the to the cameras it is friday afternoon, 4:30 p.m. let's listen in thank you very much. this is eight days that we've all sitting in this courthouse this is biden indictment. it's an order to try and win an election. political opponent nothing like this has ever happened eight days you know. >> the economy is falling apart down. now you saying it very little growth, it's going to get worse. oil prices are going

up. >> you have the college campuses all over, glows our country is going to hell. >> and we sit here day after, day after day, which is their plan. let's they think they might be able to eat, got an election. but i as the bulk numbers are very good for us, i just want to say that i've invited biden to debate a can do it anytime you want, including tonight. ready? do we find it up to the courthouse and he has tied up in the distillation hoping that through washington it's a well related attack on a political opponent. >> but here, i'm ready, willing, and able, and to be once i'll build on they night tuesday night, or wednesday night. >> we'll be at michigan state that his destroyed because of the photo industry we're not going to have any jobs left michigan don't want to jobs left and michigan, they're all going over the china and other places with his ridiculous ev mandate electric vehicle mandate. but we're willing to

do monday night, tuesday night since the night thursday night, or friday night on national television, we're ready. just tell me where i will do it in the white house. i would be very comfortable actually. >> but, you anywhere but we're reading these obviously not showing up now we hear nothing. but he said that, oh, i left it vague, but he wanted to bake. i don't think of the main maybe you will maybe i'm not sure he has a choice but that's the story. >> so here we are. we're ready, willing, and able, and we don't see him and i don't think he'll be here but maybe next week he'll do it. i doubt it and making actually itself, i just want to thank everybody for being here and now you have to suffer through this like everybody else nothing is done. this is a case that should have never been brought every legal scholar, every legal expert, any mccarthy jonathan and every single one, jonathan turley came out with a scathing report

in this trial today any mccarthy scale? hey report marked can't believe this is happening in our country. this little case here, there's no case whatsoever. it's a disgrace we, have a conflicted, judge, and it shouldn't be happening, not in this metric. thank you very much. you should be nine. >> so far all right. >> donald trump, the 45th president of the united states, and the defendant in this case talking after a full week of court. let's bring in cnn's daniel dale, are fact-checker, who's looking into everything we just heard from the formal former president, most of which was criticizing the trial and telling the world that he's ready to debate. president biden whenever, wherever it can happen. daniel. >> fair enough. he said something that we fact-checked, i think five times in the last couple of weeks, he said this is a biden indictment. it's a

well-coordinated attack coming out of washington completely baseless, zero evidence whatsoever. this is an indictment approved by a grand jury of new york citizens. there is no basis for any claim that president biden had a personal role in it. the prosecutor behind it is manhattan district attorney alvin bragg, who is a locally elected official, does not report to the federal government. now, former prime president trump has repeatedly cited the fact that a former doj official went over to work for bragg. that's matthew colangelo who'd been talking about zero evidence that president biden had any role in that personal employment decision. colangelo's and bragg were former colleagues in the state attorney general's office i think it's also worth noting, jake, that when former president trump says, every legal expert thinks this case is a sham and so on. the people he named today, he named mark levin, who yes. talks about the law he's also a right-wing radio host who's a frequent defender of donald trump, andy mccarthy sometimes criticizes trump, but as also a conservative commentator,

jonathan turley, a professor who defended trump in the impeachment contexts and other things. so yes, there are even liberal professors anti-trump professors, and so on who have questioned this case. but those names are the regular, the usual suspects defending donald trump. and then i'll note he talked about michigan being destroyed no more auto jobs. i think some of that was that prediction, but it's worth noting there are more auto manufacturing jobs today, more people employed in michigan in that industry today than there were when donald trump left office. >> all right. daniel dale with just a a combo platter of a fact checks from the feast that mr. trump just a served up. thank you so much. i appreciate it. let's talk more about the case. because it is a fairly significant case just to step back for one sack now the trial is over for the week. i want i want to talk about some of the takeaways from the cross-examination of david pecker by emil beauvais, who is it was an interesting, interesting q&a in this

back-and-forth with emil bove vein who is a defense attorney for mr. trump pecker acknowledged that negative press for trump's foes was generally good for business pecker said that if the false door man allegations had been true, he would have run the story after the election beauvais elicited from pecker that catch and kill. the term catch and kill buying a story in order to not run it so that it doesn't run anywhere else to protect mr. trump in this case, allegedly, tkatchenko was not discussed at the august 2015 meeting? the defense elicited from packer that he wanted nothing to do with the stormy daniels allegations and the defense made sure to spell out for the jurors that the karen mcdougal deal was reviewed by an election law attorney, jim. do any of these standout to you as important? bits of information for the defense of donald trump for the defense, i would say, you know, in hopefully you set this up an opening statement, but you need

to just kinda pound home that were not fighting every single fact that moves in this case, we're not fighting whether or not i wouldn't be fighting the relationships doesn't matter. it's no more than the doorman which was demonstrably false. you still pay money in nuisance suits. two people that probably don't deserve that money. so again, i think that it's not that the prosecution is doing a bad job at all. they're kind of leading in a protective way where they're getting undeniable facts out. there's a lot of scandal, a lot of salaciousness in your opening is the defense hopefully you pull the teeth on that simon, you said, look, you're going to hear all sorts of stuff. that sounds gross, that makes you disrespect any of the players that were involved, but that's not what this trial is about. and then hold to that in your cross-examination by not challenging stuff, you don't need to challenge, make everything a friendly cross until you get to cohen. >> oh gosh, what do you make of the fact? that the fact that david pecker had a election law and election law attorney, look at the karen mcdougal deal and

just to remind folks, the karen mcdougal deal, this was a playboy playmate who alleged having a ten to 11 month relationship with donald trump. she had a story and what happened was that the tabloid magnate david pecker in ami, his company hired her. i gave her $150,000 to write a column for a different magazine in their end-to-end prior, i think it was health or health and fitness or something like that. she never wrote anything. she was paid $150,000 but they had apparently david pecker had an election attorney look at this. this deal was going on. >> i think right before the 2016 election as well. yeah. well, it the implication would be that there was no actual election law violation as a result of these types of deals. right. so he has a lawyer ticket over. apparently the lawyer blessed it. right. and the deal with stormy daniels is strictly shuffle actually very, very similar, right? so that's sort of the implication. i don't think it actually is that potent of an observation. i don't i doubt we're going to hear from that lawyer in the course of this trial, which would be necessary to actually

make that useful. >> let's let's go to our attorneys outside the room right now. i'll start with bill brennan. what's your what's your big takeaway from today if anything or if you want to look at the week in general, if if any gloves were laid on mr. trump or not? >> jake, i really don't think so. i heard on kush layout a scenario and certainly he could be correct with regard to actions taken in furtherance of a political motive, but any married man in this position is going to be very worried about a jury of one and that's the person he lives with. and we had another former president who had been accused of a dalliance with someone not as wife and apparently denied it and then had to walk that back in from what i had read at the time, it was a tougher so to his wife than it was to the country. so i think any married

man on the jury, any married person female on the jury is going to get that and i also heard some talk about well, look at this, the billy bush tape comes out and the timing, and here's when colin's going in i challenge anybody to tell me a favorable time to have that come out. if you're married and have children and i really think that's going to resonate with the jurors as far as cohen and this banker, this also, i think validates the defense of not wanting to be embarrassed or to deal with his wife. colon wouldn't even tell his wife about the, uh, hundred and $30,000 loan. so i really think that there's a strong narrative that if this if it happened that it happened because the defendant was worried about the implications that would have on his family and his marriage and if that is what it's limited to when the prosecution can't tie it up to the other crime, the cases out

the window. >> so misty marris, it is it has been said by david packer, who so far this week has been the key witness that he was doing this for trump and his campaign not necessarily exclusively, but he did mention the campaign. any number of times. what's your take on what bill just said? >> well that's exactly what the defense is going to say. bill laid it out that number one, these payments on their own are not illegal. so the prosecution will have to point to unlawful conduct and the other piece of this is to the extent that we're looking at a campaign finance violations, it's this concept of mixed motive that there's reasons to make these payments that are outside of the election now, the flip side of that is exactly what we heard today. the timing, the timeline is really, really critically important for the prosecution's case. and of course, pecker's testimony that was his perception that this was all about the election that's what he testified. well, that is going to be part of how the prosecution tries to

show that the intent was directly related to the election and not all of these other reasons why somebody might make a payment like this. >> stacey schneider, your tank i think david pecker damaged donald trump this week. >> i think that the manhattan district attorney's office has a plan and that's to prove a local new york state violation of its election law and they're slowly setting it up with these witnesses to go that route. i don't think it's going to be a federal violation, although the da's office has signaled in the beginning of this case in april 4 of 2023, when they announced the indictment that they were looking at donald trump for allegedly violating both state and federal federal election law. but i think that they're really going for the new york state angle here. we'll see with the rest of the witnesses. >> all right. stacey and misty and bill, thanks to all of you. have a wonderful weekend if you're just tuning in the manhattan hush money cover up, trial wrapped for the week. donald trump just spoke, he repeated the other big story of the day saying that he is ready

to debate president biden whenever wherever president biden said something similar today, we're going to take a short break and we're back in a moment find a great deal for your ideal hutto opened your vargo typing where you wanna go. >> select your check-in, check-out dates. search compar you've got xfinity wifi at home. take it on the go with xfinity mobile. customers now get exclusive access to wifi speed up to a gig in millions of locations. plus, buy one unlimited line and get one free. that's like getting two unlimited lines for twenty dollars a month each for a year. so, ditch the other guys and switch today. buy one line of unlimited, get one free for a year with xfinity mobile! plus, save even more and get an eligible 5g phone on us! visit xfinitymobile.com today. from chavez and huerta to striking janitors in the 90s to today's fast-food workers.

californians have led the way. now, $20/hour is here. thanks to governor newsom and leaders in sacramento, we can lift workers out of poverty. stop the race to the bottom in the fast-food industry. and build a california for all of us. thank you governor and our california lawmakers for fighting for what matters. shao powering progress the whole myth has to be re-imagined feed if you didn't know whether you were next, they are both tied up yeah. yeah. i was called in and i saw what turned out to be the biggest heist in history it went from gold medal winning icon to a pariah how it really happen with jesse l. martin sunday at nine on cnn our

pharmacy has been in business for nearly 100 years. >> my wife and i have run it for the last 30 american technology is making this more efficient and customer-friendly we use online tools to fill prescriptions process insurance claims, and make deliveries. but some in washington want to undermine the technology tools we rely on. their misguided agenda. we'll so empower our foreign adversaries and hurt small businesses like ours are leaders need to strengthen, not weaken american technology vital window seem to be a typical choice here in the local area, some companies even advertise high-quality vinyl and romer here before you invest in vinyl windows, listened to what michael smith of renewal by anderson has to say with our temperature swings, vinyl tends to warp, which causes condensation between the pains and drafts. >> and most final windows just look very low-end to begin with. our customers don't want that. >> and what are renewal by anderson's windows made of? >> our windows are made out of a thermal polymer composite

material called 05 rex. it's beautiful like wood, but it doesn't require the maintenance of wood. and we engineered it to be two times stronger than vinyl. so you're getting a window that will really last now, this is innovation. >> you have a feature on your windows that allows for a better view our true seen screens are made out of an ultrafine stainless steel mesh, which is virtually invisible. you get less dirt buildup, more fresh air circulation, and a better view out of your windows. >> now, if we're talking about comfort, how much does the glass matter? >> the glass in the window makes a huge difference our high performance, low e4 smart sunglass is infused with silver oxide. it's engineered to help keep the cold air outside in the winter and keep the warm air outside in the summer. it also blocks 95% of the harmful uv rays that fade your furniture and your hardwood floors well, that's impressive, michael. thank you. >> and right now, renewal by anderson has a great offer for homeowners before april 30th by

one window, patio door or entry door, and get the next one, 40% off. that's 40% off with a minimum of four units plus saban, extra 30 yeah, dollars on every window and door you buy with no money down, no monthly payments and no interest for one year. this offer ends april 30th for a free appointment with renewal by anderson call one that's one i mourn liermann at the pentagon and this cnn as we've been following trump's hush money cover up trial in manhattan. >> another major political story line played out, that is a possible presidential debate. president biden, in an interview on the howard stern show on sirius xm, said he would be happy to debate the presumptive republican nominee, donald trump i don't know. if you're going to debate, your

opponent. >> i am somewhere i don't know why. i'm happy then donald trump responded to biden's willingness just minutes ago. >> when he walked out of court but we're willing to do monday night, tuesday night, wednesday night, thursday night, or friday night, or national television, we're ready to start where i will do it at the white house. >> that would be very comfortable but i'm back with my panel. let's turn to our political wise women trump, ready to debate joe biden. joe biden, ready to debate donald trump? >> well, i mean, trump basically has been saying this non-stop. they put things no, but his rallies now talking about how they say that biden will debate him. so this certainly will take some of the wind out of their sales because they have been using this, although he might he wouldn't debate any of his republican opponents during the primaries. we should know. yeah, he felt that and to be fair, i mean, they still feel really good about that decision and they don't feel like it was warranted whether or not it was

for integrity purposes and intellectual purposes, who who's to say i will say biden's announcement of this did not seem like some well-planned campaign strategy was kind of off the cuff because howard stern asked him, are you going to debate donald trump? this has been something of discussion when you talk to biden surrogates and they had never said outright right? yes, this debate will be happening. they'd kinda not offered a real answer. so it is notable. i don't think anyone believes that biden would is going to take trump bubble. what is offered to debate outside the courthouse in manhattan tonight especially since donald trump says he's going back to florida. but it also said he was willing to have the debate at his at a trump rally. >> what tomorrow night or something, when was it? >> i think he was talking about next wednesday, what he's two events scheduled. i mean, no one is taking it seriously, but i will say news organizations did reach out to the campaigns and say they did believe a debate was important.& that one should happen. trump's campaign has tried to get them to move the debates earlier to add more because they believe it's to their benefit whether or not they do one or more than one, it remains to be seen.

>> what do you think caitlin is point about biden just sort of put it out there as biden does i actually think this could be a mistake and it doesn't take wind. most of trump's stake by biden? yes because katelyn pointed out that at the trump rallies, he keeps goading biden. when are you going to debate? >> well, now, biden is said, i'll debate. >> and trump is going to what it's trump to every day he wakes up looking for a fight. now he has one where is biden? he said he wanted to debate me. i'm ready here. yeah. monday, tuesday, wednesday, so i think trump will play into this the way that he could just point to precedent, which is that one we've never had a general election start. shirley campaign and to the debates aren't typically until closer to the election. yeah, i think the earliest they've ever been the timber yes. in the modern era, very interesting stuff before, are attorneys go and enjoy their friday night? i just want to get your final

thought on this momentous week. the first week ever were a former president of the united states is a criminal defendant in court your thoughts on what's happened so far. >> well, it is quite remarkable that we're here. but in terms of the trial itself and how i'm thinking about it broad trials tend to be tedious. they tend to get tedious. and so there's gonna be more tedious testimony but the common metaphor that prosecutors use is talking about building their case brick by brick. so we're seeing a lot of bricks being inserted here. now whether it will all add up to a conviction at the end of the day remains to be seen, but that's a process that's going on right now. >> how do you think the prosecution has done with their bricks i think they've done fine, but we're not at the main event yet, right well, michael cohen for sure but also at some point there is going to be need to be some presentation indicating whether and to what extent trump knew any of this was unlawful, right? we

haven't heard any of that yet. now, all this stuff i was talking about earlier, the circumstantial evidence surrounding the michael cohen's shell companies and all that. the defense's response is going to be cohen, did that right? >> jim? >> well, i agree with that. i think that more and more it's looking like the critical intent stuff they need is going to come from one guy and one guy only yeah. >> there was no i thought in the abstract, maybe hope pick says something not even mentioned that opening statements. and by now, the defense has her statements. what the gold jencks material her prior statements. so both sides kinda know what's coming from these witnesses, and they didn't flag her an opening statement. and i think that was a logical flashpoint. on this issue of intent, but really, i again, not to fast forward to utter boredom. but when you talk about jury instructions, this judge can dramatically affect the verdict by either saying the government has to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that this was fully intended to be election interference. my words or the judge could say,

if you find that some portion of the motivation was to affect the election, then you have this mixed motivation model that i think misty made mention of where it's partly personal and the wife, it's also partly police political aspirations. if you have combinations allowed the support of conviction by the jury instruction, than two lawyers on the jury might run with that and 12 people could be an animus that's a real scary part for the defense to deal with. very interesting stuff. you guys have been so great to have this week. thanks so much hope. we hope we're going to see you next week and you can join caitlin& just just a few hours on her show, the source, her big gas tonight, former attorney general, bill barr. let's tonight at nine eastern here on cnn and only here on cnn. much more in the legal space coming up, we also need to bring you up to date on a dramatic situation unfolding a tornado on the ground near lincoln, nebraska, that breaking news next every weekday morning, cnn's five things has what you need to get selling with your day. it's the five essential stories of the

morning in five minutes or less cnn's five things with kate bolduan streaming weekdays exclusively on macs lag brand luck and good guys houston's are better with the credit god's on your side comment for awards once available to the few are now accessible to the many earn points for travel with credit one bank and liz large hey, there, brenda. >> it's carroll actually.

>> so which like are we operating on? >> you mean arm it's all connected asking the right question can greatly impact your future. you share your an orthopedist, actually, a a sagittarius specially when it comes to your finances, give a question a, us certified financial planner? yes. i'm a cfp professional cop professionals are committed to acting in your best interest. >> that's why it's gotta be a cfb bind your cfp professional, and let's make a plan doubt or we handcraft every stearns and foster using the finest materials like indulgent memory foam and ultra conforming and telecoil for a beautiful for mattress and indescribable comfort, every single night stearns and foster, what comfort should be the future is not just going to happen, you have to make it. and if you want a successful business, all it takes is an idea and now becomes a future online in minutes with the power of ai, we really don't want people to think of feeding food like ours, a spoiling their dogs good real food is symbol that

looks like this smells like food. it's what dogs are supposed to be eating. no living being should ever eat processed food for every single meal of their life. it's amazing to me how many people write in about their dogs changing for the better the farmers dog is just our way to help people take care of them it's kubota orange days shot the year's biggest election of kimono equipment gets 0% apr for 84 months or $3,300 off select compact directors, find your nearest dealer actor botha, orange days before planning the wedding your bad hip was really acting up then you heard about maiko robotic assisted hip replacement it starts with a ct scan to pinpoint the problem that becomes a personalized 3d plan to guide your doctor during surgery maiko can help lead to better outcomes. like less pain

and shorter recovery time the lifetime of a hip implant is limited and revision surgery may be required individual results and recovery times very risks of surgery include pain, infection, heart attack, stroke, death, and other serious risks ask ur doctor four important safety information to find a doctor who uses maiko visit maiko i can phone call from the boss. >> sorry. >> outdoor time. it's meat. they're going to the boss. that sounds fine. we have sort of a flat hierarchy, so flow isn't the boss. >> you can say, i'm a boss at helping people save when they bundle very cringy upon his first day of retirement, marcus rogers made a track with them, so i will never again work for another man or woman, or todd especially common i lay down my badge, abandoned my corporate flip phone plan and i'll get a new plan with consumers

cellular without a contract, without sacrificing comfort let's go burn when freedom calls, we're here to answer cnn saturday morning starting tomorrow at eight on cnn this is cnn breaking news and we have some breaking news off the top of this, our a dangerous storm situation right now in nebraska city of omaha, let's go straight to cnn's chad myers in the scene and weather center teared you're actually quite familiar with this? >> this area. tell us about the situation unfolding right now yeah, this was a violent tornado just a few minutes ago across highways six also, i at just to the east of the city limits of lincoln. >> now, this storm has continued to move to the north and will be affecting bennington, blair, and the like. this was a violent tornado on the ground that cross over the interstate. we do know their damage and also